The right to protect oneself, one’s family, or one’s property against an unlawful attack is a general principle recognised by the criminal justice system in UAE. However, the law does not permit individuals to use violence merely because they feel threatened or involved in a disagreement. There must be a genuine and immediate threat, and any defensive action must satisfy the conditions prescribed under the law. This principle is recognised as the Right of Legitimate Defence under Article 58 to 61 of Federal Decree-Law No. 31 of 2021 on the Promulgation of the Crimes and Penalties Law.
Under Article 58, an act committed in the legitimate exercise of the right of defence does not constitute a crime. In simple terms, a person who uses reasonable and necessary force to protect themselves or another person from an immediate unlawful attack may be exempt from criminal liability, provided all the legal requirements are satisfied. The purpose of this provision is to protect individuals who are compelled to act in circumstances where waiting for police intervention or assistance from public authorities that may not be practically possible.
Conditions for Exercising the Right of Legitimate Defence
The law provides four essential conditions that must be fulfilled for a person to successfully exercise legitimate defence.
- Existence of an Immediate Danger
The first requirement is that the individual must face an immediate danger arising from a forcible criminal act against their person or property, or against another person’s person or property. The law also recognises situations where the defender genuinely believes that such danger exists, provided that the belief is supported by reasonable grounds.
- Inability to Seek Timely Assistance from Public Authorities
The second condition requires that the defender must be unable to approach the public authorities in time to prevent the danger. This recognises that situations involving sudden attacks may leave an individual with no practical opportunity to contact the police or seek immediate assistance.
- Absence of Any Other Means to Repel the Danger
The third condition requires that the defender must have no other available means of preventing the danger. In other words, the use of force should not be the first response where the threat can reasonably be avoided or prevented through another effective means.
- Necessity and Proportionality of the Defence
The fourth condition is particularly important. The defensive action must be necessary to repel the attack and proportionate to the danger faced. This means that the force used must not exceed what is reasonably required to stop the threat.
Limitations on the Right of Legitimate Defence
Although Article 58 recognises the right of legitimate defence, Articles 59 and 60 of the same law impose important limitations.
Under Article 59, legitimate defence does not generally justify premeditated murder. However, the law provides specific exceptions where such action is intended to repel particularly serious threats, such as
- an act reasonably feared to cause death or serious injuries,
- forced sexual intercourse or sexual assault, kidnapping, certain serious offences involving arson, destruction or theft, and
- unlawful entry into an inhabited house at night.
Similarly, Article 60 restricts the right to resist public authorities when an officer is lawfully performing official duties. An exception exists where there are reasonable grounds to fear that the officer’s actions may cause death or serious injuries.
Importantly, Article 61 provides some protection to the members of the public authority where they exceed the limits of legitimate defence in good faith. Such excess may be treated as a mitigating excuse, and the judge may grant a pardon where appropriate. Nevertheless, this provision does not automatically absolve the person of criminal liability.
Conclusion
The right of legitimate defence under UAE law is an important legal safeguard that allows individuals to protect themselves, their families and their property against immediate unlawful attacks. However, it is not an unrestricted licence to use force. The law requires the existence of an immediate danger, the inability to obtain timely assistance from public authorities, the absence of another effective means of protection, and a defensive response that is necessary and proportionate.
Ultimately, whether an act qualifies as legitimate defence depends on the particular facts and evidence of each case. CCTV footage, medical reports, witness statements, photographs and police records may all be relevant in establishing the nature of the attack and the circumstances surrounding the defensive response. Anyone involved in a criminal complaint arising from an alleged act of self-defence should therefore ensure that the available evidence is properly preserved and presented before the investigating authorities and the court.
